![]() |
|||
|
|||
Textbook of Adult Emergency Medicine
(2nd edition)
Peter Cameron, George Jelinek, Anne-Maree Kelly, et al
(eds). Published by Churchill Livingstone (part of Elsevier), 2004. ISBN
0443072892. Contains 934 pages. Price ₤45.99
The first edition of this book was published in the year
2000. In the field at that time were Rosen’s Textbook (an American text,
mostly for reference, or for the very dedicated reader), Fulde’s
Emergency Medicine, The Principles of
Practice, and Brown’s Emergency
Medicine, Diagnosis and Management (both good, succinct house surgeon
level books by Australian authors), and Tintinalli’s
Emergency Medicine: A Comprehensive Study
Guide (a North American book used by many advanced trainees in Emergency
Medicine as a key text to guide their fellowship exam studies).
The Cameron book came onto the market as an Australasian
alternative to Tintinalli, and was immediately popular. The second edition is
nearly 200 pages longer, with a new section on Orthopaedic emergencies and an
expanded Toxicology section. In addition, there are new chapters on Research
Methodology, Refugee Health, Observation Wards, and a variety of Administration
issues (including dealing with complaints and risk management).
The chapters are well presented, all following a set format,
and mostly well written. The majority of authors are Australasian (five and a
half New Zealanders), with a handful of Northern Hemisphere contributors, and
most are practicing Emergency Physicians. The result is material which is
relevant, pragmatic, and appropriately supported by background information. This
is a very good book for those working in Emergency Departments, for use as a
reference or for study.
The inclusion of an Orthopaedic section is welcomed although
it reveals a gap—there is no discussion of carpal injuries. There is
evidence of the material being made current, with additions to many sections.
Examples include the chapter on refugee health and discussion of the toxicity of
gamma hydroxybutyrate. However, SARS doesn’t make it in. These are minor
concerns, which the third edition is sure to address. In summary, I like this
book. I have two copies and I recommend it as a reference book for all New
Zealand Emergency Departments, and as a study guide for those who wish to study
Emergency Medicine.
Conflict of Interest
Statement: Mike Ardagh is a contributing author to both editions of
Cameron’s textbook. He did get both of his copies of the 2nd edition
without paying—however, he has no financial gain from sales of the
book.
Mike Ardagh
Professor of Emergency Medicine Christchurch School of Medicine and Health Sciences |
|||
| Current
issue | Search journal |
Archived issues | Classifieds
| Hotline (free ads) Subscribe | Contribute | Advertise | Contact Us | Copyright | Other Journals |