![]() |
|||
|
|||
Antioxidants – a health revolution
Carolyn Lister. Published by New Zealand Institute for Crop
and Food Research, Ltd 2003. ISBN 0-478-10832-X. Contains 96 pages.
$19.95
At the same time as our bodies are being battered by free
radicals, our minds are being bombarded with information espousing the health
benefits of antioxidants. Damaging free radicals are implicated in many
diseases, but definitive proof of protection by antioxidants is sparse. While
scientists battle with the complexities of the field, the simplistic concepts of
the ‘bad’ free radical and the ‘good’ antioxidant have
been adopted by various alternative health and cosmetic industries. These
disciples, with a gospel that promises to cure or protect against all ills,
should make an intelligent person wary. However, it would also be unwise to
ignore a promising field of research because of over-enthusiastic
proponents.
For those seeking enlightenment, Dr Lister’s book is
an excellent place to start. It is clearly written and very well presented. The
layout and style will appeal to a broad audience, and the boxes, tables and
bullet-point recommendations all convey information quickly and in an easily
digestible form. Dr Lister is particularly good at describing the different
classes of antioxidants and their primary dietary sources. She also sensibly
promotes the value of a balanced and varied diet, as opposed to supplementation.
The majority of studies showing protective effects are associated with increased
fruit and vegetable consumption, while clinical trials with individual
antioxidants have been consistently negative.
While Dr Lister’s approach is generally balanced, the
evidence of health benefits is overstated in some parts. The use of the word
‘revolution’ in the title is a case in point. I hope the proponents
are right – after reading the book I went and bought a salad for lunch. If
it triggers others to think about and modify their diet, then great. However,
the evidence for antioxidants as the cure for or protector from all ills remains
unconvincing. Overall, I would strongly recommend this book as a general
resource for those with an interest in nutrition.
Mark Hampton
Department of Pathology and Molecular Medicine Christchurch School of Medicine and Health Sciences |
|||
| Current
issue | Search journal |
Archived issues | Classifieds
| Hotline (free ads) Subscribe | Contribute | Advertise | Contact Us | Copyright | Other Journals |